Assessment of the Need for Palliative Care for Children
Three country report: South Africa, Kenya and Zimbabwe
On 8 November 2013, UNICEF and the International Children’s Palliative Care Network (ICPCN) announced the results of a collaborative research project to quantify the need for children’s palliative care in three sub Saharan countries – Kenya, South Africa and Zimbabwe.
Significant numbers of sick children suffer and die without access to palliative care. Less than 1% of children in Kenya and less than 5% of children in South African and Zimbabwe who are in need of palliative care are able to access these services. Research released today reveal an enormous gap between the need and provision of specialised children’s palliative care services across these three countries.
The Report “Assessment of the Need for Palliative Care for Children. Three Country Report: South Africa, Kenya and Zimbabawe,” carried out by Stephen Connor, PhD, and Chenjerai Sisimayi, MSc is the first study to look at the prevalence of life-limiting illness and life-threatening conditions in countries in the developing world, and compare this with the coverage of palliative care services, to identify the gap between them, and develop a methodology that can be used to estimate the global need.
The knowledge that so many children are suffering needlessly and dying in pain and so few children have access to palliative care services in these countries is something that should steel every one of us to action. This important research provides us not only with evidence of the enormous need but also a methodology that can be used by other countries to calculate their own needs and gaps in services.
There has been a growing awareness of the need for children’s palliative care services, particularly in the developing world, made more urgent by the vast numbers of children dying from complications from HIV and AIDS, non-communicable diseases like cancer and other complex chronic, congenital and neonatal conditions. However, to date the actual extent and nature of the need has not been adequately documented and estimates have ranged from 9 to 20 million children.
By adapting the methodology used in this study, researchers can assess the need for children’s palliative care services in every country which will in turn lead to a clearer and more accurate picture of the global need for children’s palliative care.
The study made use of data obtained from sources such as the institute for Health Metrics and Evaluation at the University of Washington and the World Health Organization’s Office of Health Statistics and Informatics as well as national reports and mortality statistics. Interviews with service providers and key informants and national associations were carried out in all three countries.
Some of the key findings of the research include:
- HIV related illnesses and neonatal conditions are the two greatest contributors to children’s mortality in all three countries while other non-malignant but chronic conditions also make up a significant number of child deaths.
- The number of children benefiting from palliative care services in the three countries is significantly low in comparison to the estimated need.
- The research estimated the number of children needing palliative care in each of the three countries as 120.5 per 10,000 children in Kenya; 151,92 per 10,000 children in South Africa and 180,63 per 10,000 children in Zimbabwe.
Recommendations in light of these findings are that greater efforts be made to integrate children’s palliative care into health systems, for more health workers in each of the countries to receive adequate training in children’s palliative care. for the creation of a demand for services through increased awareness of the benefits and the prioritisation of children’s palliative care on funding agendas.
Craig McClure, Chief of HIV and AIDS, UNICEF Headquarters had this to say about the research: “UNICEF’s mandate is to protect the rights of all children everywhere. Our priority is that children survive and thrive, from birth through to adulthood. When children suffer from chronic or fatal illness, it is their right to be free of pain and to die with dignity. Sadly, all too often this is not the case. This study is an important first step to better understand the need and the gap in coverage of palliative care for children.”
Download a copy of the research report: Palliative Care_Three Country Report